A moronic run-out decision
Yesterday, in the Bangladesh v Pakistan game
at the Asia Cup, Pakistan's Umar Amin was declared run out
by the third umpire for no apparent reason.
He had driven the ball to long-on and taken a single. Since the bowler, Mahmudullah, was bowling from around the wicket, Umar walked across to the other side, oblivious to the fact that his bat was not grounded and no part of his person was grounded behind the 'popping crease' at the bowler's end.
Mahmudullah saw this and took off the bails. The on-field umpire got confused and handed over control to the third umpire. After multiple views, Umar Amin was ruled out.
This, despite law 23 (Dead ball
) explicitly saying that a ball was dead when it was finally settled in the hands of the wicket-keeper or the bowler. Yes, the bowler's end umpire has to be satisfied that the fielding side and both batsmen also considered the ball to not be in play.
But even the smallest bit of common sense would indicate that there was no way Umar was attempting a second run. He was switching ends.
The ball was most definitely not in play.
Where's common sense when you need it most?
At least in the Murali run-out by McCullum
instance, Murali actually walked out of the crease. Whether it was to attempt a second run or to congratulate Kumar Sangakkara is a moot point.
In Umar Amin's case, there's no way he was out!
Labels: asia cup, bangladesh, laws, pakistan, umpires